The Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment (CABE) has launched a fresh attack on supermarket-led regeneration, despite its recent work with the retail operators on improving design quality.

In an article published today, the government’s design adviser slams supermarket-led schemes, describing them as “generally very poor”. CABE also questions the way architecture and places are being “created in the image of the retailer.”

Leading supermarket operators expressed surprise at the comments, and pointed to ongoing discussions with the commission aimed at tackling design issues. CABE’s comments are based on reviews of 15 retail-led regeneration projects, in which it has been highly critical of supermarkets’ efforts to create attractive schemes.

Particular concern is raised about the pressure on councils to accept poorly designed schemes from supermarket operators to secure affordable housing units and community facilities.

Tesco has previously referred to supermarkets’ ability to develop housing supported by retail revenue. ASDA and Sainsbury’s have developed mixed-use schemes in partnership with housing developers, but Tesco in particular has stepped up its housing development in recent years.

Tesco’s proposals for a supermarket-led scheme in Bromley-by-Bow, which included 293 homes, came in for criticism from CABE earlier this year.

Today’s article renewed the criticism, claiming the scheme gives priority to the store rather than trying to create a sustainable neighbourhood.

A Tesco spokesman said: “These significant investments provide jobs and vital housing in areas where many others are unwilling to invest. CABE has supported Tesco schemes such as West Bromwich and Woolwich.

“It is a shame that our continued positive work with CABE on these projects and many others is not mentioned.”

Retailers have been calling for CABE to establish a supermarket design review panel — a proposal that has so far been rebuffed by the commission.

Jonathan Refoy, Asda head of property communications, said: “We argued for national design guidance for supermarket developments in our submissions to the PPS4 consultation.”

Design guidance for the sector was due to be issued by CABE early this year but is yet to appear.

• Tories propose competition test powers for councils
• Supreme Court rejects Wolverhampton decision over Tesco CPO
• HCA appoints design and sustainability chief
• Watchdog MP slams Labour regen “daydream”
• Farrell to champion design in Ashford